Advertisement

Unpermitted construction in Israel: buying without inheriting the risk

Unpermitted construction in Israel: buying without inheriting the risk

A closed-in balcony to enlarge the living room, a room added on the roof, a basement converted into a studio: in Israel, these alterations are common, and often carried out without a permit. For the buyer, the trap is twofold: the irregularity does not appear on the land registry, and the law places the burden on whoever occupies the property today, not only on whoever built it yesterday.

I. What is unpermitted construction?

Israel's 1965 Planning and Building Law sets out a simple rule: any construction, extension, or modification of a building requires a building permit (היתר בנייה) issued by the local authority. The only exception in principle is a internal change (שינוי פנימי), work that affects neither the façade, nor the structure, nor the common areas, and that changes neither the apartment's surface area nor the number of units. A regulation also exempts a few minor works from permit requirements, under certain conditions.

Everything else is prohibited construction (עבודה אסורה) : closing in a balcony, adding a floor, a room on the roof, an extension into the garden, splitting an apartment into two units, a parking space or storage room converted into housing. This also covers what was built under a permit but beyond its conditions.

II. Why the buyer inherits the problem

Many buyers believe the violation belongs to the seller who carried out the work. The law distinguishes the act of building fromprohibited use (שימוש אסור), which simply consists of using what was built without a permit. This use is a continuing offense, renewed every day, and the law names among those responsible the owner of the property at the time of the facts and whoever actually occupies it. Only the tenant living on the premises is expressly spared. The day you become the owner of an apartment whose rooftop room was never authorized, you are the one "using" a prohibited construction.

Since the 2017 reform, the administration has tools that no longer require going through court:

  • stop-work orders and orders to cease use;

  • a administrative demolition order (צו הריסה מינהלי), reserved for recent constructions: unfinished work or work completed only a few months ago, housing not yet lived in or occupied for only a few weeks;

  • administrative fines, set by regulation, imposed without a trial;

  • for older constructions, a judicial demolition order, which the court can issue even without criminal proceedings, including when the construction offense itself is time-barred.

Criminally, prohibited use exposes one to a daily fine for as long as the offense continues after a written warning, and the court may add a fine calculated on the value of what was built. Not having carried out the work yourself is not a defense: at most, it affects the severity of the penalty.

III. The concrete consequences for your purchase

  • Financing : the expert appointed by the bank compares the property to the permit. Unauthorized areas are generally excluded from the valuation, which reduces the loan granted.

  • Resale : your future buyer's lawyer will carry out the checks described below. What you did not see when buying, you will have to explain when selling.

  • Co-ownership : an unauthorized extension consumes building rights that belong to the whole building, and can block other co-owners' projects.

IV. How to check before signing

The Nessah Tabou (נסח טאבו), the land registry extract, says nothing about the compliance of the work: it describes rights, not walls. Checks must be done elsewhere.

  • The building file (תיק בניין), kept by the local planning committee (ועדה מקומית) or the municipality, contains the permit and approved plans; many cities post it online.

  • Comparing the permit plans with the actual state of the premises, with an architect or engineer.

  • For a recent building, the occupancy certificate (טופס 4), which certifies that the building was received in compliance with the permit, without guaranteeing what was modified afterward.

  • The existence of a demolition order, ongoing proceedings, or a pending fine, to be requested from the local committee.

  • The seller's written statements in the contract, and the questionnaire that the real estate agent must now have them fill out, which includes a section on irregular constructions.

V. What to do if an irregularity appears?

An irregularity does not necessarily doom the purchase, but it must be dealt with before signing, not after.

The regularization (היתר בדיעבד), a permit obtained after the fact, is possible when the work complies with the applicable urban plan. It requires a file submitted by an architect, fees, and sometimes a Heitel Hashbaha (היטל השבחה), the betterment levy, when the committee grants a waiver. If the work contradicts the plan, the only way out is restoration to the original state.

Contractually, the buyer can require the seller to regularize or demolish before handing over the keys, negotiate a price reduction, have a precise statement from the seller about the property's compliance written into the contract, and arrange for part of the price to remain held in escrow by the lawyer until the permit is issued. These clauses carry weight: in 2019, a Tel Aviv court ordered a seller who had concealed surface area overruns to pay the compensation provided for in the contract, without the "as is" clause protecting him, because his compliance statement was false. A lawsuit after the fact, however, remains worse than a check beforehand.

Conclusion – Why get help from a lawyer when buying a property with construction irregularities?

A buyer living in France will often visit the property only once or twice, and will not read the permit or the plans in Hebrew. The lawyer's role is to examine the building file, have the plans compared to reality, question the local committee, and then translate the result into clauses: seller's declaration, regularization condition, escrow, price reduction. And, if proceedings are already underway against the property, to tell you clearly whether you should walk away. When it comes to unpermitted construction, Israeli law does not forgive ignorance: it must be checked before signing.


Originally published on immobilier.co.il.
More articles